7 Thanksgiving Pies That Aren't Pumpkin

Original Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie 2

Pumpkin pie is quintessential during Thanksgiving and definitely deserves accolades. Have you ever thought about adding another sweet counterpart to the dessert table, though? Check out these 7 Delicious Pies that go beyond pumpkin and will impress (and delight!) your dinner guests at the end of any meal.

1. Original Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Original Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Creamy. Decadent. Delicious. That's all you need to know about Original Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, and we know you are going to love it! When you have layers of creamy peanut butter filling topped with a creamy chocolate pudding-like layer all atop a graham cracker crust, well, game over. This is a warehouse of flavor you can't get enough of. Original Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie is the perfect dessert showpiece that your guests will adore. Think outside the dessert box with this little beauty!

Click Here >>

2. Apple Buckle

Apple Buckle

Buckle in, because Apple Buckle is going to take your tastebuds for a spin! Apple Buckle is cake-like and tender on the bottom and topped with crunchy nuts, hearty oats, warm cinnamon sugar, and of course sweet apple slices! It's like an apple cake and an apple pie together at last, with a rich caramel sauce drizzled on top. Apple Buckle is a country culinary masterpiece!

Click Here >>

3. Turtle Pie

Turtle Pie image

Turtle Pie makes all the pie similes come true. Is it as sweet as pie? Yep, there's a creamy chocolate layer stacked on top of a peanut-filled caramel layer that all sits on a buttery, chocolate-covered pie crust. That's pretty delightful and tasty! Is it as easy as pie? Oh, you betcha! All you need is a fridge and a little bit of time, and you've got yourself some Turtle Pie! This will help everyone come out of their shells!

Click Here >>

4. Fall Dessert Bake

Fall Dessert Bake

What happens when an apple pie, a berry pie, and a cobbler come together to make a dessert that truly defines the harvest season? The Fall Dessert Bake, of course! The filling is pure ooey-gooey jammy goodness, with tart apples and sweet berries sweetened with brown sugar and a touch of cinnamon. Meanwhile, the crust is an extra crunchy buttermilk treat, loaded up with almonds for nuttiness and an extra crisp sensation. Indulge in the Fall Dessert Bake and you'll find yourself fully immersed in that true autumn feeling!

Click Here >>

5. Pecan Slab Pie

Pecan Slab Pie

Pecan Slab Pie stretches out the beloved Thanksgiving dessert into a rectangle... a rectangle that's even more suited for sharing than any circle could ever be! The crust is buttery and flaky, the filling is rich, creamy, and even a little tangy, and the top—with that crunch of caramel-coated pecans—beckons you closer with their candy appeal. You'll just want to put a huge slab of Pecan Slab Pie on your plate!

Click Here >>

6. Shut-My-Mouth Sweet Potato Pie

Shut My Mouth Sweet Potato Pie

Can sweet potato pie really compete with the other fall favorite desserts? Of course, it can! This pie will prove it so perfectly you'll have to eat your words... and another slice. Shut-My-Mouth Sweet Potato Pie is caramel-sweet and fluffy on the inside, supported by a buttery, flaky crust and with hints of autumn spices throughout! Top it with a little whipped cream and Shut-My-Mouth Sweet Potato Pie will have you silent as you focus on having another bite!

Click Here >>

7. Peachy Pecan Bake

Peachy Pecan Bake-1

Peachy Pecan Bake wants to see what happens when you cross a peach cobbler with a pecan pie. The results — amazing! The interior filling is all peach cobbler, with the floral and juicy peaches cooked until jammy and extra tender. Meanwhile, the crust is actually loaded with crunchy pecans and more sugar for true dessert decadence before it's all baked until golden-brown. Peachy Pecan Bake is going to make sure the transition from summer to autumn is a smooth and sumptuous one!

Click Here >>

Are you salivating yet? If you choose to have dessert first, we won't tell!

Related Articles