Federal Employee Still Missing After Killing Family

William Bradford Bishop Jr. appeared to have it all. A Yale-educated State Department official with a globe-trotting career, he spoke multiple languages, played tennis at the country club, and doted on his family in their idyllic Bethesda, Maryland, home. But beneath the polished surface, Bishop wrestled with financial troubles, professional disappointment, and an explosive temper. On March 1, 1976, the mask shattered in one of the most horrifying crimes in modern American history.

The Day Perfection Crumbled

That day began like any other — until everything changed. Bishop left his State Department office early, claiming he felt unwell. On his way home, he stopped at a bank to withdraw $400, bought a gasoline can and a sledgehammer, and returned to his quiet suburban house. According to the FBI, Bishop allegedly used that sledgehammer to bludgeon his family to death — his wife Annette, his mother Lobelia, and his three sons, 14-year-old William III, 10-year-old Brenton, and 5-year-old Geoffrey. He loaded their bodies into his station wagon and drove six hours south to Columbia, North Carolina, where investigators believe he dumped them in a shallow grave, doused them in gasoline, and set them on fire.

A coroner later determined the family died from blunt force trauma. Authorities linked Bishop to the crime through fingerprints found on the gasoline can and blood at the home, but by the time the evidence came together, Bishop had disappeared.

A Vanishing Act for the Ages

Bishop's maroon station wagon turned up weeks later at the Elkmont Campground in Great Smoky Mountains National Park in Tennessee. Inside the car, investigators found two blood-stained tarps, a blood-stained blanket, an axe, a shotgun, and personal items like toiletries, men's clothing, and cigarette butts. Yet Bishop was gone.

Sightings trickled in over the years — from Stockholm to Sorrento — but none panned out. In 2014, the FBI exhumed a John Doe from Alabama who resembled Bishop, only to confirm through DNA testing that the man wasn't him. The fugitive who the FBI described as a longtime insomniac who was "intense and self-absorbed" and "prone to violent outbursts" remained one of their most wanted, according to PEOPLE.

A DNA Test Changes Everything

Then in 2017, Kathy Gillcrist, a retired teacher in North Carolina, decided to search for her biological parents. As an adoptee, she had always been curious about her roots but had never felt a pressing need to investigate. With time on her hands after retiring, she took a DNA test to piece together her family history. What she uncovered shocked her: Her biological father was likely William Bradford Bishop Jr. — a man who allegedly murdered his entire family and one of the FBI's most wanted fugitives. "It just was surreal," Gillcrist told the New York Times. "It still is surreal."

With the help of a third cousin and amateur genealogist, Gillcrist built a family tree that pointed to Bishop. The physical resemblance stunned her — her nose and mouth mirrored his — and she wondered if her flair for drama and bouts of insomnia might also connect her to the man who vanished after a gruesome crime. "I can't go there," Gillcrist said of the murders, as reported by the New York Times. "It's just too heinous for me to imagine."

A Legacy of Trauma

Gillcrist's discovery rekindled interest in the case, drawing responses from people connected to the tragedy. "That traumatized him for the rest of his life," she said of the forest ranger who found the burned remains of her father's victims, as quoted by the New York Times. She has since published a book about her experience and asked the FBI to compare her DNA to Bishop's, a request they denied, citing confidentiality rules.

Where Is William Bradford Bishop Today?

Now presumably in his late 80s, Bishop could still be alive. His disappearance — and the possibility of his survival — remains a chilling puzzle. For those left in the wake of his crimes, the trauma lingers. Gillcrist herself holds mixed feelings. "Do I want him to knock on my door? No, thank you," she told the New York Times. But she admitted she would consider meeting him in a "supervised setting."

William Bradford Bishop Jr.'s story stands as a haunting reminder of the hidden darkness that can fester behind the facade of a perfect life. For the families shattered by his actions and those like Gillcrist, who must grapple with his legacy, closure feels both elusive and essential.

References: Inside the Terrifying Case of an Ivy League Grad Who Had It All, But Killed His Family and Became Fugitive | Woman's Search for Her Birth Parents Leads to a Story of Murder | DNA test reveals connection between North Carolina woman and killer wanted by FBI