Truthfully.com

America's Oldest Prisoner

The Eight-Decade Incarceration of Francis Clifford Smith

The story of 99-year-old Francis Clifford Smith presents a narrative deeply entrenched in history, justice, and the stark reality of lifelong incarceration. Having been imprisoned since 1950, his nearly 8-decade confinement challenges our perceptions of crime and punishment.

The Beginning of a Lifelong Sentence

In 1950, a decisive moment in the life of Francis Clifford Smith unfolded, altering his destiny irrevocably. Smith was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of a night watchman, a crime committed during a robbery at a yacht club in 1949. This severe judgment marked the inception of what would become one of the longest sentences in the history of the United States penal system.


Initially, Smith faced a far grimmer fate – execution. He was mere hours away from meeting his end in the electric chair, a stark testament to the severity with which the justice system dealt with such grave offenses at the time. However, in a dramatic turn of events, and under circumstances that remain a part of the case's enduring mystery, his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. This last-minute reprieve from the death penalty spared his life, but condemned him to an indefinite future behind bars.

Decades Behind Bars

Smith's life in prison has been marked by events like an escape in 1967, parole, and subsequent re-incarceration in 1975. Despite continued claims of innocence and appeals, his attempts for retrial were unsuccessful.


The Mystery and Debate

The case of Smith is shrouded in mystery and debate. The details of the murder are not clear and Smith may not have actually fired the weapon that killed Hart (Smith had two accomplices). Questions about the appropriateness of his prolonged sentence and doubts about his actual role in the murder persist.

Psychological Impacts

The prolonged incarceration has likely led to Smith becoming 'institutionalized', losing touch with the outside world's realities.


Francis Clifford Smith's story serves as a testament to the severe realities of the justice system.

References: The Longest Serving Prisoner In History Is Still Serving His Sentence After 71 Years | Frank Smith was locked up for eight decades. At 98, what would it mean to be free?

Related Articles