Fight Club McDonald's^®: Brooklyn Store Cards Teens

A McDonald's^® in Flatbush, Brooklyn, has implemented a surprising new policy, requiring teenagers under 20 to show ID and be accompanied by a parent to enter the restaurant. This drastic measure comes after a wave of unruly behavior by local teenagers — transforming the fast-food location into what some have called a "fight club."

Why the New Policy?

The decision was driven by a series of incidents involving local teens, including fights, theft, and even an attack on a security guard by a group of teenagers wearing ski masks. According to the restaurant's manager, Amber Hussain, the young customers often caused chaos by throwing ice at patrons, snatching food from delivery drivers, and smoking marijuana inside the establishment.

Videos of the newly quiet McDonald's have circulated online, contrasting the peaceful atmosphere with stories of past violence. Some local customers noted that the restaurant had a notorious reputation for fights and even stabbings.

Is This Normal for McDonald's?

While McDonald's locations have occasionally needed extra security, a strict ID policy like this is rare. Typically, fast-food chains deal with rowdy behavior by adding security guards or implementing no-loitering rules — not by barring an entire age group. According to the New York Police Department and as reported by ABC 7, the Flatbush McDonald's has seen 29 police visits this year alone, underscoring the severity of the problem.

Have Other Restaurants Tried This?

While unusual, this isn't the first time a fast-food restaurant has restricted entry to certain age groups. Similar measures have occasionally been used in other cities, particularly in areas where teenagers gather after school. However, these instances are typically short-term responses to specific incidents rather than ongoing policies. The franchise owner emphasized that the safety of staff and customers was the top priority stating, "As a Brooklyn-born military veteran and local business owner for over 30 years, I have deep respect for this community. This measure to ID customers is another way we're prioritizing the safety and security of our people within our lobby." He also suggested the ID check could be a temporary measure until the situation improves, according to ABC 7.

What's Next for This McDonald's?

For now, the ID policy remains in place, supported by three security guards who enforce the rule. The effectiveness of this strategy remains to be seen, as some teenagers still managed to enter without issue. High schoolers in the area noted that the age limit had previously been set at 18 before being raised to 20 — a choice that many found puzzling.

The McDonald's situation in Flatbush highlights the ongoing challenge of maintaining a safe and welcoming environment in public spaces. Whether this strict approach will inspire other businesses to adopt similar policies — or face backlash — remains to be seen.

References: New York City McDonald's starts carding teenagers in response to crime: 'People fight in there' | Brooklyn McDonald's carding customers under 20 after owner says unruly teens terrorizing restaurant