Jason Kelce's Bedtime Tale Terrifies Daughter
The Washington Commanders fall to the Philadelphia Eagles 24-8 from FedEx Field in Landover, Maryland, September 25, 2022. Photo courtesy of Joe Glorioso / All-Pro Reels under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Jason Kelce's bedtime storytelling took a wildly unexpected turn when a creative twist on a classic tale left his 4-year-old daughter terrified and his wife, Kylie Kelce, furious. On the December 3, 2025, episode of the "New Heights" podcast, the retired NFL star shared the hilarious yet revealing story of how he improvised a version of "Pinocchio" that featured his daughter Elliotte Ray's beloved stuffed animal, Slothy, coming to life. What was meant to be a magical moment quickly spiraled into a frightful experience for little Elliotte, sparking a sharp reaction from Kylie that exposed the playful chaos of modern fatherhood.
Jason Kelce, known for his charismatic presence on and off the football field, has embraced fatherhood with a mix of creativity, humor, and a dash of unpredictability. He and wife Kylie share four daughters: Elliotte Ray, 4; Wyatt Elizabeth, 6; Bennett Llewellyn, 2; and Finnley Anne, about 8 months old. While Jason's storytelling often aims to blend timeless moral lessons with fun, this particular bedtime tale took a spooky detour that no one saw coming.
A Stuffed Animal Comes to Life and So Does the Fear
Jason explained that his daughters sometimes request their favorite stuffed animals to be part of the bedtime stories. On this occasion, Elliotte asked for Slothy to be included in the "Pinocchio" story, as reported by PEOPLE. Jason, eager to please and entertain, wove Slothy into the narrative as a living character who magically came to life after Elliotte wished upon a star. He even incorporated a Jiminy Cricket figurine to maintain the classic conscience theme of the story.
But the imaginative addition backfired spectacularly. "The only thing after the story, Ellie was just so terrified that she was holding [the stuffed animal]," Jason shared, as reported by PEOPLE. The moment was so intense that Jason's wife Kylie was left furious, confronting him with a blunt question saying, "What the f--- is wrong with you?" The episode of parental experimentation, while lighthearted, revealed the delicate balance parents walk between creativity and comfort when entertaining young children at bedtime.
The Kelce Family's Playful Parenting Style
Despite this frightful episode, Jason remains a devoted bedtime storyteller and singer for his daughters. He has reportedly expressed a fondness for classic children's stories that have stood the test of time, such as "The Boy Who Cried Wolf," which he uses to teach important life lessons like honesty and trust. His approach mixes traditional tales with his own imaginative twists, aiming to engage his children while imparting values.
Jason's candid sharing of this bedtime mishap offers a glimpse into the joys and challenges of parenting in the spotlight. It's a reminder that even celebrity dads face the same unpredictable moments as any parent, where a well-intentioned story can suddenly become a source of fear or laughter. Kylie's reaction adds a layer of realness, showing the dynamic between parents as they navigate the ups and downs of raising children together.
Life as a Girl Dad in the Kelce Household
Jason's role as a father to four daughters has been a defining part of his life since retiring from professional football in early 2024. He has openly described being a "girl dad" as the biggest highlight of his life, embracing the unique joys and challenges that come with raising daughters, as reported by PEOPLE. A recent Instagram video reportedly captured a tender moment of Jason practicing his golf swing while his daughters Elliotte and Wyatt recorded him, showcasing the playful and loving atmosphere in the Kelce home.
Jason has shared that before having children, he intended to treat daughters the same as sons, raising them "tough" and unspoiled, as reported by PEOPLE. However, the reality of fatherhood apparently softened that resolve, as he quickly realized the special bond and tenderness that comes with raising girls. Kylie has also revealed amusing details about their daughters' nicknames for Jason, including Elliotte's "big guy," a term she picked up from a children's show, adding to the family's lighthearted vibe.
The Unexpected Hilarity of Parenting
The bedtime story incident is more than just a funny anecdote. It highlights the unpredictable nature of parenting, especially when creativity meets the vivid imaginations of young children. Jason's willingness to share this story publicly reflects a refreshing honesty about the trials and errors that come with fatherhood. It also underscores the importance of family dynamics, where moments of frustration, laughter, and love coexist.
For fans and followers, this glimpse into the Kelce family's life offers a relatable and endearing portrait of a celebrity dad who is as human as anyone else when it comes to raising kids. The blend of classic storytelling, personal flair, and the occasional parental misstep makes Jason Kelce's approach to fatherhood both entertaining and authentic.
What's Next for the Kelce Clan?
As the Kelce family continues to grow and evolve, Jason's storytelling adventures are sure to provide more memorable moments. Whether it's a bedtime tale that inspires or terrifies, or a playful nickname that sticks, the Kelces embody the vibrant, sometimes chaotic, but always loving spirit of modern family life.
For now, Jason Kelce's bedtime story mishap stands as a charming reminder that even the most creative dads can stumble and that sometimes, the best stories are the ones that don't go as planned.
References: Jason Kelce Says His Bedtime Story to Daughter Ellie, 4, Left Wife Kylie 'Furious' | Jason Kelce's Daughters Look All Grown Up in Rare Video at Home with Dad
